Why We Should Read Scott Today

Summary of the Talk:

This essay explores why Sir Walter Scott, once an immensely popular literary figure, continues to be relevant and worth reading today despite a perceived decline in his modern readership.

1. Scott's Reputation:
2. Scott was a literary lion in his time, but his popularity has waned in recent years. His novels are often no longer part of school curricula, but this decline may not be entirely negative. Many still read his work, with the Waverley novels frequently reprinted, and academic interest remains strong.
3. Scott's Political Views and Persona:
4. Scott’s Tory political stance, which was once mainstream, now puts him at odds with modern Scottish nationalism. His position on the Union and political conservatism is a barrier to broader appeal. He was also part of the British Establishment, which impacts how his work is perceived today.
5. Scott the Man vs. Scott the Writer:
6. The perception of Scott’s moral character, especially his virtue and Stoicism, has influenced how his work is viewed. Some may find his personal life and his status as a gentleman writer to be a hindrance to appreciating his artistic merit.
7. Criticism of Scott's Writing:
8. Scott’s writing has been criticized for being “heavy” and “trivial,” with some believing he lacked artistic detachment. Yet, Massie argues that Scott’s writing is accessible, and the sense of delight in his work outweighs these flaws.
9. Why Read Scott Today?
10. Scott is a classic Scottish novelist and a crucial figure in European literature. Not reading him is to miss out on a deep understanding of Scottish history, culture, and literature.
11. Massie quotes the Italian writer Italo Calvino, who defined a classic as a book that offers new discoveries upon rereading. Scott’s novels meet this definition, as they are rich with historical, cultural, and moral insights.
12. Scott also helped shape the concept of Scotland as a nation and is essential for understanding the evolution of Scottish identity and the Scottish novel.
13. Scott’s Strengths:
14. Scott is not just a storyteller, but a teacher and enchanter. His novels are compelling, deeply engaging, and sometimes mysterious. He offers a vivid portrayal of Scottish life, often balancing high drama with humour and social commentary.
15. Influence and Legacy:
16. Scott influenced many later writers, including those who shaped modern European literature. His works, including Ivanhoe and Rob Roy, had a lasting impact on both British and European literary traditions.
17. Massie suggests that even in modern times, Scott's influence is felt in many genres, including historical fiction and crime novels.

Notable Insights:

• Scott’s Uniqueness: Scott is praised for not being a perfectionist but rather a writer who was driven by a genuine love for storytelling. His writing, while sometimes heavy, is still profoundly engaging, with a charm that endures.
• Scott’s Relevance Today: Despite his outdated political views and the decline of his popularity, Scott’s novels still offer vital lessons on the complexity of history, national identity, and human nature.
• Humanity in Literature: Scott’s works give readers a chance to understand human character in various circumstances, making his novels timeless in their emotional depth and understanding of society’s intricacies.

In conclusion, Massie makes the case for Scott’s continued importance, both as a storyteller and a historical figure, asserting that his works are vital for understanding both Scottish culture and broader European literary traditions.